The Vanilla Index · Free procurement tool

Supplier Price Increase Pushback Playbook

Supplier asking for more? Enter the old and new price and roughly what the product is made of. We compare the increase with the published price of the raw material over the same months, show how much it explains, and give you three emails to send.

The increase

Raw material reference

Published change: +35.3%

What the price is made of, and how each cost changed
Raw material
Freight & logistics
Currency (FX)
Labour & processing
Overheads & margin

Shares add up to 100% (must be 100%). Raw material change is filled in from the published reference; you can overwrite it.

What the figures explain

Supplier's increase
+12.0%
Raw material
+21.2%
Freight & logistics
0.0%
Currency (FX)
0.0%
Labour & processing
0.0%
Overheads & margin
0.0%
Explained by cost changes
+21.2%

Not explained by these inputs

-9.2 pts

A price of about 121.16 would match the cost changes, versus 112.00 asked (-9.16 per unit).

This is arithmetic on your inputs and a published reference, not a finding that the supplier is overcharging. Quality, energy, volumes or contract terms can explain the rest — ask.

Copy-paste negotiation emails

Filled in with your figures. Edit the names and check the numbers before sending.

On these figures, cost changes explain the whole increase, so only the cost breakdown request is shown. Check the inputs before pushing back.

1. Ask for a cost breakdown

Hello [name],

Thank you for letting us know about the proposed +12.0% price change. Before we can approve it, could you send a breakdown of the increase by cost element (raw material, freight, currency, labour and overheads), with the reference period you used for each?

This will help us take it through our internal approval quickly.

Kind regards,
[your name]

The four-step pushback playbook

  1. Don't accept or reject straight away. Acknowledge the notice and check your contract for fixed-price periods, notice terms or index clauses.
  2. Ask for the cost breakdown. A supplier with a real cost increase can usually show which costs moved and when (email 1).
  3. Check it against a published reference. Compare the raw material change with an independent series over the same months, as above, and keep freight and currency separate.
  4. Negotiate on the gap. Agree what the figures support, ask about the rest, and propose a review date or index-linked clause so prices can fall as well as rise (emails 2 and 3).

Common questions

How do I know if a supplier price increase is justified?
Ask for a cost breakdown, then compare the change in each cost with an independent reference over the same period. If raw material is 60% of the price and its published price rose 10%, that explains about 6 percentage points of the increase. The rest needs its own explanation.
Can I refuse a supplier price increase?
That depends on your contract. Many supply agreements fix prices for a period or require notice and evidence for changes. Check the terms, then negotiate on the figures rather than simply refusing.
Does an unexplained difference mean I'm being overcharged?
No. Quality, currency, minimum volumes, energy costs or contract terms can all justify part of an increase. It's simply the part to ask the supplier to explain.

Sources

Supplier blaming currency? Check the wire fee for your currency pair