Decoding Cocoa Premium Invoices: Tracking West African Port Arrival Shortfalls Against Butter and Powder Processing Markups
How West African port arrival shortfalls feed into bean differentials, and how cocoa butter and powder are priced against the bean, so you can see where a processed-cocoa invoice gets its premium.
Introduction
A cocoa invoice rarely has one price. Beans are usually priced as a futures reference plus an origin differential, and processed products such as cocoa butter and powder are priced as a multiple, or ratio, of the bean price. A high invoice can come from any of those layers.
This guide explains each layer and the supply signals behind it. It gives no live differential or ratio figures; those are set in private contracts or published under licence. A difference from a reference is a reason to ask questions, not proof of overcharging.
1. The Layers of a Cocoa Bean Price
Most physical bean contracts can be broken into three parts.
- Futures basis: ICE London (in sterling) or ICE New York (in US dollars), for a named delivery month. The ICCO daily indicator on our cocoa page averages the nearest futures months; it is context, not an origin offer.
- Origin differential: An amount above or below futures for beans from a specific origin, quality and shipment period. It moves with how tight supply is at that origin.
- Delivery and terms: FOB origin port, CIF a European port or delivered to a warehouse, plus payment terms, certification premiums and traceability programmes.
2. Reading West African Port Arrival Shortfalls
Côte d'Ivoire and Ghana supply most of the world's cocoa, so the pace at which beans reach their export ports is watched closely during each season.
- What arrivals are: Weekly estimates of beans delivered to the ports of Abidjan and San-Pédro, compiled by exporters and reported by news agencies. They are estimates, not official statistics, and different reports can disagree.
- Why shortfalls matter: Arrivals running behind the previous season can signal a smaller crop. Exporters who have sold forward may struggle to deliver, which can lift origin differentials and delay shipments.
- Official prices at origin: Côte d'Ivoire's Conseil du Café-Cacao and Ghana's COCOBOD set farmgate prices paid to farmers each season. These are not export prices, but changes to them affect what exporters pay and offer.
- What to ask: If a supplier cites weak arrivals to justify a higher differential or late shipment, ask for the shipment period, contract origin and how the new price compares with their original offer.
3. How Butter and Powder Are Priced
Grinders turn beans into cocoa liquor, then press it into cocoa butter and cocoa cake, which is milled into powder. Because butter and powder come from the same pressing, their prices are often quoted as ratios to the bean futures price.
- Butter ratio: Cocoa butter price divided by the bean futures price. Butter is in higher demand for chocolate, so it usually trades at a multiple of the bean.
- Powder ratio: Cocoa powder price divided by the bean futures price. Powder demand comes mainly from drinks, baking and confectionery, and can move separately from butter.
- Combined ratio: Butter ratio plus powder ratio. The trade uses it as a rough guide to grinding margins: when butter is expensive, powder can be cheap, and the reverse.
- Reading a processed invoice: Ask which bean reference and month the ratio applies to. A higher price per tonne can come from a higher ratio, a higher bean price or a different reference month.
4. Questions to Put to the Supplier
A short written checklist makes two cocoa offers comparable.
- For beans: Which futures market and month, what differential, which origin and crop, and what shipment period?
- For butter and powder: Is the price fixed, or a ratio to which bean reference? What fat content, alkalisation and colour does the powder have, and is butter natural or deodorised?
- Quality and documents: Bean count, moisture, defect limits (cut test) and certificates of analysis for each lot.
- Terms: Incoterm and named place, payment terms, and who bears the cost of late shipment.
- Next step: Use the cocoa "Am I overpaying?" guide to compare the bean part of the offer with the dated ICCO reference.
